Follow Simon Caulkin on Twitter



Article Archive
2021
September
August
July
June
May
April
February
2020
December
October
September
August
July
June
May
March
February
2019
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2018
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2017
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2016
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2015
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2014
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2013
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2012
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2011
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2010
December
October
September
2009
November
October
June
May
April
March
February
January
2008
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2007
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2006
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2005
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2004
December
November
October
September
August
July
June
May
April
March
February
January
2003
December
November
1998
January
1997
January
1996
February
1994
May


A tale of two viruses

Thu, 25th Feb 2021

Covid-19 is giving us a grim crash course in evolutionary biology. Every day we anxiously check the state of the existential race – are people being inoculated fast enough to suppress the disease before a ‘fitter’ Covid variant emerges to take up the baton for an even tougher stage?
But wait. As in a horror movie, just as the frantic vaccination programme seems to give grounds for a glimmer of optimism on one front, it dawns that we are at the same time struggling with an equally toxic mutant on another front, man-made this time, that has erupted in the last few months and may be even harder to douse than the coronavirus.
In a blistering essay in the New York Times, Shoshana Zuboff, author of last year’s monumental The Age of Surveillance Capitalism, makes a direct link between the storming of the Capitol in Washington on 6 January and the data extraction and manipulation business model of Big Tech, specifically the social media companies.
Facebook, Google, and Twitter are to blame for the riot, she declares: ‘The intolerable truth of our current condition is that America and most other liberal democracies have, so far, ceded the ownership and operation of all things digital to the political economics of private surveillance capital, which now vies with democracy over the fundamental rights and principles that will define our social order in this century’.
We have a choice between surveillance capitalism or democracy, she believes. We can’t have both.
Over the top? Judge for yourself. Zuboff’s charge is that we are in the third stage of what she calls an ‘epistemic coup’ that began 20 years ago with the discovery by Google of the value of the personal data that internet users unwittingly gave up in surfing the web, followed by its permissionless annexation of that data for its own use.
That was the first stage of the coup. It quickly led to a second phase of growing epistemic inequality as companies amassed incomparably more data about us than we imagine or than we have about them and their algorithms. The perilous third stage is epistemic chaos, ‘caused by the profit-driven amplification, dissemination and microtargeting of corrupt information, much of it produced by coordinated schemes of disinformation.’
That’s where she thinks we are now, and looking around – at Trump and Trumpism, at Brexit, at mushrooming conspiracy theories and social unrest – it’s hard to argue she’s wrong.
And this of course is the nightmare scenario, where the twin viruses of Covid and surveillance capitalism intersect and reinforce each other. The surveillance model of capitalism is so toxic because it has no interest in the truth or otherwise of the content it carries; its currency is engagement – and as all the research confirms, wild stories, fake news and conspiracy theories, previously majoring on Trump, now on Covid,  get more clicks, and therefore personal data to store, analyse, and sell on, than boring reality.
Which is why social media firms only censor or ban purveyors of such theories as a last resort, and why they will fight to retain the protected status granted them by Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act of 1996, their great enabler, which absolves them of responsibility for the content they carry, to the bitter end. It is their major asset.
It also explains why other companies, with a few exceptions, do little to contest the power of Big Tech. As Rana Foroohar succinctly puts it in Don’t Be Evil: The Case Against Big Tech, ‘they are the ones buying what the Valley is selling’. What’s more, they are also collecting and trading data on their own account.
Surveillance is catching. Every company with a website does it (including the newspapers that we read online) – and that is before the full advent of the Internet of Things, which will multiply the opportunities for data capture exponentially.
In effect, hidden below the visible economy where companies buy and sell products and services there is a swelling invisible one consisting of the extraction and manipulation of personal information. It is claimed to be the fastest-growing industry in the world, its value (although no one knows for sure) estimated at around $200bn in the US alone.
In politics as in commerce, the hacking of humans has real-world effects. Crudely, these are what’s being bought and sold. One of the most serious is the growing difficulty of splicing splintered truth back together. Simple truth no longer carries weight. It is no accident that those who believe the ‘alternative facts’ of political conspiracy are also more likely to believe that Covid is a hoax or caused by 5G masts or part of a plot for a world government of the elite. Adherents of QAnon not only storm the Capitol in support of Trump – they are more likely to refuse face coverings, social distancing and vaccination.
Worryingly, this viral superstrain is not confined to the US. Anti-vax sentiment is particularly strong in France, where the gilets jaunes and other extremist groups, no strangers to violence, have emerged as its natural carriers. In the UK, health chiefs warn of facing two pandemics: one spread by a virus, the other by unregulated social media companies. ‘We have to fight both with equal vigour,’ says the head of NHS England.
The starkness of the civil dilemma this poses is summed up by a reluctant quarantiner in Hong Kong who ruefully notes that the powers that enable Hong Kong to tackle the virus so effectively – the power to lock her up in in a quarantine hotel room for three weeks with an electronic tag and the threat of legal sanctions – are the self-same ones that are also being used being to stamp out political uprising.
Bringing Covid under control therefore has a double urgency: not only to prevent the outbreak of more virulent disease variants but also to head off what can only be called a looming mental-health pandemic, whose effects are unpredictable. They could be as dire as those of the physical infection.
Stamping out the surveillance bug will be harder, requiring whole-system change. Yet ironically Facebook itself just may have brought the belated regulation of social media a small step closer.
Its decision to black out news feeds in Australia (including government and local information sites) in response to that country’s proposal to make platforms pay publishers for content was quickly rescinded. But in a fierce backlash it was widely branded not just as petulant and hubristic, but also counterproductive.
And not just by its sworn enemies. Interviewed on the BBC’s Today programme (at 2:48:40 in) on 23 February, a former Facebook high-flyer expressed fears that strikingly echoed Zuboff’s. While Facebook did good things, and Zuck was ‘a good person’, he was just too powerful, said Steve Sheeler, CEO of Facebook Australia and New Zealand until 2017.
‘In Australia, I can vote for or against the government at the next election, but I can’t vote for or against Mark Zuckerberg – his own shareholders don’t control him. That’s the problem we’re up against here: sovereign nations are coming up against Facebook, yet they’re not on the same playing field in terms of power.
‘A few years ago I thought breaking up Facebook or Big Tech was a fool’s errand, and ridiculous, because their powers weren’t anything like what the critics were saying. But in the past couple of years I’ve come round to the view that the scale, size and influence of these platforms, particularly on our minds and brains and all the things that we do as consumers and citizens, are so powerful that leaving them in the hands of a very few closely controlled companies like Facebook is a recipe for disaster.
Facebook and the social media had played a major part in events ranging from controversy around the 2016b US presidential election through the Cambridge Analytica scandal to the recent riots in Washington, he pointed out. ‘It’s not going to get better if we allow the industry to regulate itself, he concluded. ‘We need to hear the government’s voice in here.

 


<< Back to Index

User comments

:: 1st Mar 21
Thanks Simon- well argued as usual. And here is more evidence: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-56071437 But what to do about it? In Oz by enacting legislation that puts controls on the Big Tech companies parliamentary control is seemingly reasserted over non-democratic multinational capital. But in the process Murdoch is supported and his support for the next election is secured by Morrison. There is also no guarantee that the extra money is going to be spent on journalists and journalism practice which freely speaks truth to power! Hence, I would argue that brings u to governance reform, change of the whole system including governing the Technosphere as we argue in Ison & Straw 2020. Ray
:: 1st Mar 21
Thanks Simon- well argued as usual. And here is more evidence: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-56071437 But what to do about it? In Oz by enacting legislation that puts controls on the Big Tech companies parliamentary control is seemingly reasserted over non-democratic multinational capital. But in the process Murdoch is supported and his support for the next election is secured by Morrison. There is also no guarantee that the extra money is going to be spent on journalists and journalism practice which freely speaks truth to power! Hence, I would argue that brings u to governance reform, change of the whole system including governing the Technosphere as we argue in Ison & Straw 2020. Ray
Henning Sieverts :: 2nd Mar 21
Ray is 100% right. And thank you, Simon, for the link to Shoshana Zuboff's piece in the NY Times. (She needs an editor to shorten her sentences and clean up her message.)
Cary Wildman :: 12th May 21
Hello from SendBulkMails.com, We have a special limited offer for you to send unlimited emails. We allow non-permission based emails and you won't ever get blocked. We also buy your domain for you and give you a clean IP and setup your DNS records. Check us out on SendBulkMails.com
Chi Grahamslaw :: 28th May 21
Hello from order-fulfillment.net, Doing your own product shipping or order fulfillment in house? Tired of it? Visit us on www.order-fulfillment.net We can store, inventory, and manage your drop shipping / order fulfillment for you. Based in the US for almost 2 decades - we ship around the world and will save you time and money. Who would be the best contact at your company to discuss? Here are some of the items we ship for clients: -Books, training manuals, guides -New member welcomes boxes and gifts -Product samples -Marketing materials -Medical program test kits -Follow up gifts to clients, leads, and prospects Thank you! Fulfillment Warehouse https://order-fulfillment.net
Lila Wozniak :: 3rd Jun 21
Hello, It is with sad regret to inform you that BestLocalData.com is shutting down. We have made all our databases for sale for a once-off price. Visit our website to get the best bargain of your life. BestLocalData.com Regards, Lila
Molly Hutchens :: 11th Jun 21
We at BestLocalData.com has been hit badly by Covid-19 and as a result BestLocalData.com is shutting down. We provided the best data to companies to find their right customer base, we don't want other companies to go down the same path we went and go out of business. As a result we are providing our data till the end of the week at the lowest possible prices. BestLocalData.com
Eloise Hardesty :: 15th Jun 21
Hello from order-fulfillment.net, Doing your own product shipping or order fulfillment in house? Tired of it? Visit us on www.order-fulfillment.net We can store, inventory, and manage your drop shipping / order fulfillment for you. Based in the US for almost 2 decades - we ship around the world and will save you time and money. Who would be the best contact at your company to discuss? Here are some of the items we ship for clients: -Books, training manuals, guides -New member welcomes boxes and gifts -Product samples -Marketing materials -Medical program test kits -Follow up gifts to clients, leads, and prospects Thank you! Fulfillment Warehouse https://order-fulfillment.net
Esmeralda McCready :: 18th Jun 21
Hello from FbCourses.net Want to pay $0.01 a click? We got you covered. A great team of Global Digital Marketing experts have compiled this list of 13 Best + Free Facebook Advertising Training, Classes and Courses to help you learn and excel at Facebook Ads & Marketing. Thousands of professionals have already benefited from this list on Facebook Training. Regards, Esmeralda
Lisette Toomey :: 28th Jun 21
It is with sad regret to inform you that because of the Covid pandemic BestLocalData.com is shutting down at the end of the month. We have lost family members and colleagues and have decided to shut down BestLocalData.com It was a pleasure serving you all these years. We have made all our databases available for $99 (All of it for $99) for those interested. Kind Regards, BestLocalData.com Lisette
Leland Glassey :: 30th Jun 21
Hi , I am following up on my message below. Who would I speak with about handling your US order fulfillment and shipping? Regards, Leland order-fulfillment.net ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Hi, Who would I speak with at your company that manages your product shipping and order fulfillment? We are US company, offering warehousing, order fulfillment and drop shipping to our customers since 2005. Here are some of the items we ship for clients: -Books, training manuals, guides -E-com product drop shipping -New member welcomes boxes and gifts -Product samples -Health and Medical supplements -Marketing materials -Medical program test kits -Follow up gifts to clients, leads, and prospects Do you have some time to discuss - phone / email ? Thanks, Fulfillment Specialist www.Order-Fulfillment.net
Elane Pride :: 27th Aug 21
We have an amazing database of leads for you. All countries are $99 and you can buy the entire world 165 countries for $179. This offer is valid till Friday. www.SunDataGroup.one
Eduardo Lynch :: 11th Sep 21
Hello from SunDataGroup.com We are selling leads from around the world. I thought your company could benefit from it. You can visit our website www.SunDataGroup.com to see some of our data. We have a special offer running. All our databases for $99.
Name:
Comment:
Check:3+1=